Roles in Occupy: A User’s Guide
by Bill Say
Role awareness is vital in not repeating the mistakes of history where the oppressed overthrow their oppressors and then become them. It’s the lack of awareness that prevents us from collectively seeing how we become the one we oppose.
The Occupy movement is a global and promising one. Yet there are already glaring tendencies when the “99%” doesn’t recognize how it needs to become the “1%” and already acts like it, unintentionally. For example, I see the amazing potential and challenge when homeless people and those deemed “mentally ill” become a sizable part of the Occupy movement. The rough “mainstream” Occupy body seems to imply that these two groups detract from the respectability and functionality of Occupy, when I would argue that they are potentially its greatest evidence that the movement is working at a fundamental basis. Marginalization, homelessness, and mental illness are practically synonymous and these groups are a basic symptom of mainstream forces pushing out minorities for various reasons and leaving them to fend for themselves.
When the “mainstream” Occupy does not work to deeply integrate these groups, they will probably become yet another minority within the movement, and here Occupy becomes the “1%” it seeks to take down.
The police. A brutal tool of the “1%” some might argue. There might be truth to that. But if Occupy does not integrate a kind of authority that can reinforce safety and order then the police are necessarily called in to fulfill this role. If Occupy crosses lines of legality into violence and unlawfulness, the police will be constellated into action. Does that really help? It creates a battle of roles but does it serve greater purposes?
Authority is somewhat linked to the “1%” and Occupy seems to have a hard time dealing with it even within its own spheres. “Authority is what we’re against,” is what I hear subtexted but without it, again, this role becomes a disturbing and missing “role” in Occupy that will be both vilified and unconsciously enacted. That’s inevitable. We can’t help but become our enemies until we face how we are that and need to be, in an essential and positive way.
The big role to integrate in Occupy is the “1%.” If Occupy survives long enough but doesn’t integrate what the “1%” really is, it will become it. I bet a nickle on that. This is not to say that Occupy should become as oppressive and greedy as the “1%” it opposes. But let’s consider what lies beneath those tendencies to get at the heart of the “1%.”
Let me digress a moment to offer a common example of role awareness and finding the essence of a role. A child gets abused by the power of her/his parents. S(he) learns to reject power as it is tied to the abuse of it. S(he) has a series of figures in life who replicate this abusive role and fends off some of the worst by defending and avoiding such situations. But s(he) also finds that s(he) lacks enough power to really succeed in key areas of life. S(he) finds that the baby of power was thrown out with bathwater of power abuse and begins to reclaim that power and authority. If s(he) is aware enough her/his expression of power is a marked improvement over her/his parent’s version and if not, replicates the abuse. So, in one instance, the essence of that abusive parent may be clear, direct action.
What might be the essence of the “1%?” There are probably many answers to this. My answer is that the essence of the “1%” is what is most fundamental and positive about it at its heart. And that essence lies beneath greed, power, and domination. Here’s my stab at it: the essence of the “1%” that controls, dominates and accumulates wealth is a god like force that creates what it wills. And if that is close to the truth, then what the “99%” need is to exact a godlike force in creating the world as it wills it to be, one that is just, equitable, and deeply democratic.
Now, how can these roles be explored? This can be meaningfully explored at any level by any individual or group. We can ask: What are the issues? Who are the roles explicitly and implicitly involved? Then play with the roles. See what their deepest expressions are. And see where the interaction goes if you really stay with the deeper levels and conflicts. Don’t let it slip away! Role play is amazing as a way for the real experiences and information to start to find its way in via the play. When my son Gabe was 4 I said to him, “hey, let’s play. You be the daddy and I’ll be the baby.” He said, “ok.” I said, “hey daddy, let’s play.” He said, “forget it. I’m too busy.” And that took about a minute but it woke me up to an important part of our relationship that I really wasn’t fully aware of because I was too busy and too busy staying in my “dad” role. Role work can give us the information and the awareness and allows anyone and any group to go beyond conversing about the world issues that affect us to working on the world. That’s Worldwork and that is Process Work.
